SECOND MEASUREMENT SM-029
The Clean Air Act gives EPA 60 days to answer a petition against a major source’s air permit. It answered 13 of 472 in time, 11 of them by dismissing the petition, and 109 petitions are still waiting past the deadline
The claim: EPA Title V petitions: the Clean Air Act gives EPA 60 days to answer; it answered 13 of 472 in time, 11 of them dismissals, and 109 are still waiting past the deadline
What we found: In EPA’s Title V Petition Database, 13 of 472 resolved petitions were answered within 60 days, 11 of them dismissed as premature in 2003; median 387 days. Since 2020, 1 of 122. All 109 pending petitions are past 60 days, 37 filed more than twenty years ago.
Status: Published; checked three times against the exhibits before publication; questions to EPA's Office of Air Quality Planning and Standards not yet sent
Refineries, power plants, chemical plants and other large sources of air pollution operate under a Title V permit, written by the state. EPA reviews each permit for 45 days. If EPA does not object, anyone has the next 60 days to petition EPA to object, and the Clean Air Act gives EPA 60 days to grant or deny that petition. Most petitions come from people living near these plants and the groups that represent them; it is how they ask the federal government to check a state permit. EPA lists the petitions it has received since 1996, with the date it was filed and the date EPA resolved it. We counted the list as it stood on 22 November 2026. Of 472 petitions EPA has resolved, 13 were answered within 60 days, 11 of them by dismissing the petition as premature; half took more than 387 days. Since 2020, 1 of 122 was decided in time. 109 petitions are listed as still waiting, the oldest filed in 1998. EPA’s own Inspector General counted the same list in 2004 and found that none of the petitions it could check had been answered in time.
- The rule: “The Administrator shall grant or deny such petition within 60 days after the petition is filed.” Clean Air Act §505(b)(2) [1]. The statute allows no extension.
- EPA’s Title V Petition Database [3], read 22 November 2026: 599 rows. 13 of 472 resolved petitions were answered within 60 days. Median 387 days; 258 took more than a year, 59 more than three years.
- Petitions filed since 2020: 1 of 122 decided in time. The medians have come down since 2022, to between 161 and 245 days, about three to four times the deadline.
- 109 petitions are listed as pending, all past 60 days; 90 were filed more than ten years ago and 37 more than twenty. The oldest was filed on 28 April 1998.
- Of the 13 on time, 11 were petitions about Bay Area refineries that EPA dismissed as “unripe” on 19 December 2003, a week after it found cause to reopen the permits. Two other petitions were answered in time: one in 1998, which we could not confirm, and one in 2022, decided on its merits.
- In 2005 EPA’s Inspector General reported that of 53 petitions EPA had to answer within 60 days, it answered none in time, and EPA agreed to find a way to shorten its responses [5]. Twenty-one years later EPA still answers almost none in time.
The rule, in their words
The Clean Air Act, §505(b)(2) [1]:
“If the Administrator does not object in writing to the issuance of a permit pursuant to paragraph (1), any person may petition the Administrator within 60 days after the expiration of the 45-day review period specified in paragraph (1) to take such action. … The Administrator shall grant or deny such petition within 60 days after the petition is filed.”
The same 60 days bind the petitioner. EPA’s rule repeats the petitioner’s deadline [2], and its guidance of 11 May 2026 tells regions how to count it to the day: day 1 is the day after the review period ends, a deadline on a weekend or holiday moves to the next business day, and “the end of a business day is midnight Eastern Time” [4]. We give EPA the same allowance: counting to day 63 instead of day 60 changes none of our numbers.
The duty to answer applies to a petition filed on time. EPA has treated late-filed petitions as releasing it from the 60 days; the Inspector General found four such cases by 2004 [5]. EPA’s table does not say which petitions it considers late-filed, so we hold every listed petition to the 60 days.
What we counted
EPA’s Title V Petition Database is one public table [3]. Each row is a petition: petitioner, facility, EPA region, state, the petition and its date, and EPA’s response and its date, or “Pending.” On 22 November 2026 it had 599 rows. We left out 11 petitions that were withdrawn and 7 whose resolution date is given only as a year (“c. 2009”). When a row lists more than one order date, because EPA answered a petition in parts, we used the earliest, which is the count most favourable to EPA. That leaves 472 resolved petitions and 109 pending. Many orders answer several petitions about the same permit; we count petitions, as the table lists them.
We corrected five rows where EPA’s own documents disagree with the table: the Kawaihae order of 1997 is signed 10 March 1997, not 1 February; the TPC Houston order is of 6 May 2026, as its file name and the table’s other row for the same order say, not 2025; the Latham petition of 2025 is dated 14 April, not 24 April; and two 2016 petitions (Welsh, Corpus Christi East) were withdrawn with a third on 25 October 2022, by a letter the table links only on that third row [9]. Each correction and its source is in the script.
| Petition filed | Resolved | Within 60 days | Median days |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1995–1999 | 16 | 1 | 284.5 |
| 2000–2004 | 134 | 11 | 328.5 |
| 2005–2009 | 65 | 0 | 470 |
| 2010–2014 | 69 | 0 | 604 |
| 2015–2019 | 66 | 0 | 703.5 |
| 2020–2024 | 87 | 1 | 204 |
| 2025–2029 | 35 | 0 | 245 |
| All | 472 | 13 | 387 |
Year by year since 2019. “Still pending” matters for the recent years: a petition not yet answered is not in the median, so the latest medians will rise as the rest are decided.
| Petition filed | Resolved | Within 60 days | Median days | Still pending |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2019 | 8 | 0 | 454.5 | 1 |
| 2020 | 13 | 0 | 461 | 0 |
| 2021 | 10 | 0 | 401 | 1 |
| 2022 | 16 | 1 | 197.5 | 0 |
| 2023 | 17 | 0 | 196 | 0 |
| 2024 | 31 | 0 | 161 | 0 |
| 2025 | 33 | 0 | 246 | 3 |
| 2026 | 2 | 0 | 173.5 | 11 |
The 13 answered in time. Eleven are petitions about the Chevron Richmond, ConocoPhillips Rodeo, Shell Martinez, Tesoro Golden Eagle and Valero Benicia refineries, filed between 21 October and 24 November 2003 by community groups, unions and the refineries themselves. On 12 December 2003 EPA found cause to reopen all five refineries’ permits, and on 19 December it dismissed every petition about them as “unripe” [7]. Two more petitions, about Valero’s Benicia asphalt plant, are marked dismissed the same day, at 66 and 67 days; we have Valero’s letter for one of them. The Inspector General left all 13 dismissals out of its count because they “do not reflect typical EPA responses” [5]. The other two: Kawaihae Cogeneration Partners’ petition about the Keahole power plant in Hawaii, filed 17 February 1998 and answered, the table says, on 3 April 1998; we found no copy of that order, and the Inspector General’s count of 1998 petitions gives a fastest answer of five months. And WildEarth Guardians’ petition about Lucid Energy’s Big Lizard compressor station in New Mexico, filed 26 September 2022 and decided in 51 days; the same order answered a second petition, filed in June, at 154 days [8].
Three Clean Air Council petitions about Delaware plants, filed in 2003 and 2004, are marked resolved on 16 January 2018 with no order linked; the oldest, about General Chemical, is the longest wait for a resolved petition, 5,464 days.
The petitions still waiting
109 petitions are listed as pending, and none has been answered within 60 days. The two newest, filed on 15 September 2026 about the DCP Sullivan Compressor Station in Colorado and Tenaska Westmoreland in Pennsylvania, passed the deadline on 14 November.
| Waiting since filing | Petitions |
|---|---|
| 61 days to 1 year | 12 |
| 1 to 5 years | 2 |
| 5 to 10 years | 5 |
| 10 to 20 years | 53 |
| more than 20 years | 37 |
Some of the oldest may be finished business that the table never caught up with. At least eight were filed by a company or by the permit holder rather than by neighbours: four by the permit holder about its own permit (R.R. Donnelley, 1998; Wisconsin Electric’s Presque Isle plant, 2000; Holsum de Puerto Rico, 2015; Schriever Air Force Base, 2021) and four by a company about another’s (Anderson Lithograph about Graphic Press, 2002; Decatur Energy Center about Solutia, 2004; A-C Equipment Services and John Vitas about Motor Castings, 2012; International-Matex Tank Terminals about Pin Oak Terminals, 2018). Either way, a petition EPA lists as pending is, by its own record, unanswered. Among them is the January 2026 petition against BP’s Whiting refinery in Indiana; its petitioners told EPA in April that they intend to sue over the missed deadline [6].
By EPA region
| Region | Resolved | Within 60 days | Median days | Pending |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 (New England) | 4 | 0 | 299.5 | 0 |
| 2 (NY, NJ, PR) | 95 | 0 | 414 | 6 |
| 3 (Mid-Atlantic) | 36 | 0 | 358.5 | 6 |
| 4 (Southeast) | 63 | 0 | 441 | 22 |
| 5 (Great Lakes) | 47 | 0 | 475 | 27 |
| 6 (South Central) | 99 | 1 | 510 | 8 |
| 7 (Midwest) | 4 | 0 | 1771.5 | 2 |
| 8 (Mountains and Plains) | 58 | 0 | 245.5 | 12 |
| 9 (Pacific Southwest) | 50 | 12 | 139.5 | 19 |
| 10 (Pacific Northwest) | 15 | 0 | 403 | 5 |
| not given | 1 | 0 | 86 | 2 |
Regions as EPA’s table assigns them; it lists one Los Angeles petition (Hitco Carbon Composites, 2003) under Region 4 and two petitions with no region or state. Region 9 (Pacific Southwest) has 12 of the 13 answered in time, 11 of them the 2003 dismissals. Regions 4 (Southeast) and 5 (Great Lakes) hold 49 of the 109 still pending in the table.
What was already known
That EPA is late is not new, and it has been counted before. In March 2005 EPA’s Inspector General, working from the same database as it stood in October 2004, reported that EPA had received 162 petitions since July 1996 and took “approximately 12 months” on average to answer. Of the petitions it could check against the deadline: “Although the Act required EPA to respond to at least 53 public petitions listed in the EPA database we reviewed within 60 days of the filed date, EPA did not respond to any within the required 60 days. EPA did respond to 45 of the 53 petitions; however, the average response time was almost 17 months.” EPA agreed “to work to devise a procedure to reduce response times to public petitions” [5]. Petitioners also send EPA notices of intent to sue over single missed deadlines; EPA posts some on its website, such as the BP Whiting notice [6]. What we add is the same count twenty-one years on, over the 581 petitions in the table we could count (472 resolved, 109 pending), by year and region, and the 109 petitions still listed as waiting. We found no count of the whole list since the Inspector General’s.
How this ends
EPA can do two things, both in its own table. It can answer, or mark as closed, the petitions listed as pending, starting with the 37 filed more than twenty years ago. And it can decide new petitions within the 60 days the statute sets, as it did for Lucid Energy’s Big Lizard station in 2022. EPA adds orders to the database as it issues them; we will recount it on the first of each month and add the numbers here.
| Table read | Resolved | Within 60 days | Median days | Pending | Pending past 60 days |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 10 Nov 2026 | 472 | 13 | 387 | 109 | 107 |
| 22 Nov 2026 | 472 | 13 | 387 | 109 | 109 |
Our questions
To EPA’s Office of Air Quality Planning and Standards, which keeps the database. Answers will be printed here as written.
- Are the 95 petitions filed more than five years ago and still listed as “Pending” awaiting a decision, or were some answered, withdrawn or found moot without the table being updated?
- Does EPA track its response time against the 60 days in §505(b)(2), and is there a target or plan for meeting it?
What we can’t be sure of
- Dates come from EPA’s table. We checked 12 orders dated from 1997 to 2026, plus the 2003 dismissal letters and the 2022 Lucid order. Every order names the petition’s date. All match the table except two: the Latham petition, ten days apart, which we corrected, and the 2004 Chevron order, which says EPA received the petition on 8 December 2004, two days after the table’s date. The 2003 dismissal letters are undated and name no petition date; the 19 December 2003 date comes from EPA’s 2004 order. Where an order’s signing date can be read, it matches the table’s resolution date except Kawaihae, which we corrected. Some signing dates are handwritten or stamped and cannot be read from the text. The orders are in exhibits/orders.
- Keahole, 1998. One of the two answers in time, apart from the 2003 dismissals, rests on the table alone. We could not find the order, and the Inspector General’s 2004 count found no 1998 petition answered in less than five months. If the table is wrong, one petition was answered in time apart from the dismissals.
- Filed versus received. The statute counts from the day a petition is filed. The table gives one petition date. In the orders we read that say when EPA received a petition, it is the table’s date, except the 2004 Chevron order, two days later.
- Partial answers. Where EPA answered a petition in more than one order, we stopped the clock at the first. Some petitions were answered in part within the year and in full much later.
- Pending may be stale. Some old “Pending” rows may have been resolved in ways the table does not show. That is the first question we ask EPA.
- Recent medians will rise. 14 petitions filed in 2025 and 2026 are still pending and not in those medians.
- Not every row is a petition. The Algonquin order of 2019 says two of the submittals the table lists “do not appear to be petitions.” We count the rows as EPA lists them.
- Rows left out. 11 withdrawn petitions and 7 with year-only resolution dates. Counting the 7 as late or on time cannot change the result: the most they could add to the on-time count is 7.
Run it yourself
curl -sL -o titlev.html 'https://www.epa.gov/title-v-operating-permits/title-v-petition-database' python3 -I analyze.py titlev.html 2026-11-22 # writes summary.json, resolved.json, pending.json
Standard-library Python 3. EPA updates the table as orders are signed, so a fresh download will differ from ours; our copy of 22 November 2026 is in the exhibits with its hash. Scripts, outputs and checksums: sm-029/.
References
- Clean Air Act §505(b), 42 U.S.C. §7661d(b), law.cornell.edu, read 10 November 2026. Saved copy 42_usc_7661d_cornell_2026-11-10.html.
- 40 CFR 70.8(d), “Public petitions to the Administrator,” eCFR as of 1 November 2026. Saved copy 40_cfr_70.8_ecfr_2026-11-01.xml.
- EPA, Title V Petition Database, epa.gov, read 22 November 2026. Saved copy epa_title_v_petition_database_2026-11-22.html (and the 10 November copy, epa_title_v_petition_database_2026-11-10.html).
- EPA, Assistant Administrator for Air and Radiation, Guidance on Streamlining Title V Operating Permit Reviews, 11 May 2026. Saved copy epa_title_v_streamlining_guidance_2026-05-11.pdf.
- EPA Office of Inspector General, Substantial Changes Needed in Implementation and Oversight of Title V Permits If Program Goals Are To Be Fully Realized, Report No. 2005-P-00010, 9 March 2005. Saved copy epa_oig_2005-P-00010.pdf.
- Environmental Law & Policy Center and others, notice of intent to sue over the BP Whiting petition, 22 April 2026, posted by EPA at epa.gov. Saved copy noi_bp_whiting_2026-04-22.pdf.
- EPA Region 9, letters to the petitioners dismissing the Bay Area refinery petitions (e.g. to Communities for a Better Environment), December 2003, and EPA’s 2004 order on the Chevron Richmond petition, which states: “On December 19, 2003, EPA dismissed all of the section 505(b)(2) petitions seeking objections to the refinery permits as unripe because of the just-initiated reopening process.” Saved copies in exhibits/orders (*_decision2003.pdf, chevron_cbe_decision2004.pdf).
- EPA, Order Granting in Part and Denying in Part Petitions, Lucid Energy Delaware (Frac Cat and Big Lizard), 16 November 2022. Saved copy Lucid_Energy_Delaware_Order_11-16-22.pdf.
- Documents behind two corrections: EPA, Order Granting in Part and Denying in Part Petitions, TPC Group LLC Houston Plant (file name of 6 May 2026), saved as tpc-houston-order_5-6-26.pdf; Environmental Integrity Project, letter withdrawing the Welsh, Corpus Christi East and Shell Deer Park petitions, 25 October 2022, saved as withdrawal_welsh_cc_east_shell_deer_park_10-25-22.pdf.